STFU and do something. - Forum by Three Retired Teamsters

STFU and do something.

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Bob Randall
    Senior Member
    • Aug 2024
    • 172

    #1

    STFU and do something.

    Been reading suggestions about "communicating" and other suggested organizing methods to address an IBT President's support for an "anti-union" POTUS and politicians. Or to do something about TDU's alleged "sellout". "Somebody should do this. Somebody should do that." Being a union member...retiree or active... is to act rather than to effortlessly suggest. Cripes! In today's world of telecommunications there is always a way to begin. STFU and be a union member.
  • WTF891
    Senior Member
    • Feb 2024
    • 598

    #2
    Calling a TURD a TURD is truth telling. The large group of former TDU members and leaders that have been publicly outspoken is an action. The fact that the TURD won't publish or repudiate the charges against Lindsay Dougherty and whitewashes the charges by the grifter Chris Griswold is further evidence of there whoring out to O'Brien and your former running mate Zuckerman. On that note I have no recollection of your organizing activities around that election. Your name was on the ballot and that was the beggining and end of your organizing prowess. Don't be a hypocrite Bob. I'll make another prediction when Victor Mineros is charged the church mice over at the TURD will have nothing to say. They sold their souls and stand for nothing, that's just the truth. It needs to be told regardless of your viewpoint. Please tell us what reformative or union building thing they have accomplished since becoming O'Briens' butt boys.



    TURD (1).jpg

    Comment


    • Nickjamesups
      Nickjamesups commented
      Editing a comment
      Even the people I know who still support Paff have a hard time explaining the lack of coverage of anything that would have been headline news ten years ago by TDU.

    • Bob Randall
      Bob Randall commented
      Editing a comment
      My post was not in defense of TDU or any other party at all. You know that. Your response is transparently a deflection so that the TDU attacks don't lose traction. Your response is more of an affirmation of my original post.

      I was a TDU member for years as well. To some extent I have been publicly outspoken about TDU and the alliance. It concerns me greatly. Moreover, my comment was not exclusive to the TDU issue. As far as to the extent of my "organizing activities" goes I have spoken out about issues that I have been ideologically opposed to over decades. However, I have always taken up actions or turned out in support of or against. I campaigned hard over long periods of time for Ron and Tom as a rank filer without my name on a ballot (NY, MA, CT, NH, Chicago). As a rank-and-file member and employee of Super Valu I spoke out often about the different Locals inability to cooperate during contract negotiations. Consequently, I would travel to other Super Valu barns to talk to members about the desire to cooperate. I campaigned against Junior during my stint with SEIU. Tips of the iceberg. Anyone who knows me can't genuinely deny that. "Hypocrite" is unfounded. But I understand your need to go there. The continuous and constant need to complain over an extended period of time, without any followed up action, about the same issues is purely self-serving and pathetic in my opinion. To consider that in and of itself to be "an action" is pathetic as well. Pounding a keyboard over and over again pertaining to the same issue is not "an action". Now, that said, there are folks that post here regularly that complain. However, I am aware of some of their actions to attempt to bring about some change. Whether I agree with them or not I applaud their actions. Some use their real name. Some don't, but I recognize them. They are not all necessarily in my thoughts with my post. As an example, Teamster Mobilize is a group of mostly very young Teamster members that have expressed their dissent for TDU as well as for SOB. They have done so on this site. I believe that they are a bit misguided with their strategies and have much to learn. However, they have at least made genuine efforts to organize, act and attempt to bring about change that they believe will possibly affect the membership in a positive way. They act. I applaud that.

      If you, or anyone else, feel offended by my suggestion to act or organize I apologize. I am being facetious here in case that was not recognized. STFU and get to work.
  • AlJackson1962!
    Senior Member
    • Apr 2024
    • 376

    #3
    Ok Bob, telling people to “shut the fuck up” regardless of the suggestion that they shut the fuck up “and organize “, may not be a great organizing tool. And how would you possibly know what other activities such people you’re addressing here, are and have been involved in? You must recognize that the vehicle for expressing dissent in our Union is limited now that TDU is in a Coalition with misleaders and is controlled by two Paff and Levin. TDU used to serve as a voice of rank and file Teamsters. You must know that is a distant memory today. So, like it or not. Read it and weep.
    - Dave ,Robbins, retired Local 251 (handle here is AlJackson 1962)

    Comment


    • Bob Randall
      Bob Randall commented
      Editing a comment
      "How"? Because you and some others (such as TM members) have publicized your actions. Whether I agree or not those are not the examples that I'm talking about. In case that point was missed it was meant as a commendation. Again...my post was not meant as a defense of TDU. Again...the responses, such as yours, transparently are no more than a reaction meant to keep the TDU traction (self-serving name calling) moving. An affirmation. Since we are talking about effective "organizing tools", constant name calling, rather than simply pointing out examples of inappropriateness as they happen is not the smartest way to effectuate change. It reminds me of the malcontents that drop off their complaints in the "suggestion box" and walk away. Constant whining and name calling absent action is what teenagers do on social media. In my mind it's just not what responsible union members do. So, to those that fit my description, STFU, make a plan, and go to work.
  • AlJackson1962!
    Senior Member
    • Apr 2024
    • 376

    #4
    Brother Randall: In response to your comment today posted above, including your defense of TDU 's "alleged sellout" in your initial post from 11/05/2026. In my mind, the allegation of TDU selling out is clear as day. It will be interesting to see if Sean O'Brien is the featured speaker at tonight's TDU banquet in Chi. It will be interesting to see if there is any dissent expressed at the TDU Convention. I remain a member in good standing of TDU today. Like my good friend Arthur Doty, Jr. who bore the greatest attacks and blacklisting from "leaders" of 1980's Joint Council 10, I'm more comfortable with being called a "malcontent" by those holding the reins of power - O'Brien, Zuckerman, Paff, Levin. The examples of misleadership by OZ is here on this site for all to see. Among the worst offenses are bullshitting the members and telling them OZ is bargaining "historic" contracts; not just the UPS debacle, the recent characterization of the recent ratification of a contract by Local 332 members at Henry Ford Genesys Hospital as a victory on staffing levels, a key demand for hitting the bricks for 411 days on strike. It seems clear that the language to guarantee staffing levels at the hospital is toothless and unenforceable for the purpose of guaranteeing nursing staff levels; same BS regarding UPS automation, layoffs, hub closures. Does it not bother you that the IBT with TDU's blessing and support is clearly bullshitting the members? Arthur Doty was ostracized and seen as a malcontent by Ken Paff but remained a member in good standing of TDU. I don't plan on giving up my TDU membership because I worked with others who helped build the TDU rank and file movement over the decades, and I remain committed to honor their struggles.

    Comment


    • OT+
      OT+ commented
      Editing a comment
      Since you referenced Henry Ford Genesys Hospital, I'm including a link from a seperate thread. I'm not promoting the articles proposed solution, but it certainly provides some information on the "settlement".
      Genesys nurses held the line for 411 days, stayed out through a winter of court injunctions, scab labor and threats of permanent replacement. While the strikers did not lack courage, they were isolated and betrayed by the Teamsters bureaucracy.

    • Bob Randall
      Bob Randall commented
      Editing a comment
      Dave...okay??? Just not sure what your point is...again...and again...and again...and aga......................... Awww, screw it. Here... rather than banging the keyboard every day over the repeated issues...as a TDU member...why don't you get together with other TDU members, make a plan and try to bore from within. That's what democracy minded, reformist union members do...right? If you have already made such a plan that I am not aware of then my aforementioned comments don't apply to you. To be frank, they hardly did anyway. If I remember correctly, you were at last year's convention taking on some activities. Personally, I think there is a huge potential resource there as a means of addressing your concerns. Yet, your continued reactions to my response are exclusively to the TDU issue. That intentionally misses my point. Not once have I had anyone respond with, "Hey! Good idea! Anyone interested?" (With respect to any matter.) Again, not exclusive to the TDU issue. Drink some herbal tea bro.
Working...