Faster Labor Contracts? Caution. - Forum by Three Retired Teamsters

Faster Labor Contracts? Caution.

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • AlJackson1962!
    Senior Member
    • Apr 2024
    • 377

    #1

    Faster Labor Contracts? Caution.

    Brothers and Sisters:

    I mailed the below letter and attached op/ed to US members of the Teamsters GEB. I had initially asked that TDU publish this op/ed (although it was a shorter version limited to 500 words David Levin advised me space was limited for submissions to Teamsters Voice by TDU members). Levin then wrote me stating that the TDU ISC rejected my submission. No reason was given, nor any info about ISC discussion).
    Oh well. I tried. I'll see if I hear back from any GEB member.

    Please read the below and I would appreciate members thoughts on this matter. I have most of my dues receipts in a shoebox, hopefully those years of membership in our Union will be worth some response.

    The last paragraph undeniably is critical as I see it. Thanks.

    Would the FASTER LABOR CONTRACTS ACT alone be a step forward for rank and file power
    and Union democracy?
    Our Union supports passage of the Faster Labor Contracts Act (FLCA). The FLCA is one of the
    provisions included in the Protecting the Right to Organize Act (PRO Act). If the FLCA becomes
    law, any newly organized bargaining unit of workers will be subject, upon impasse in
    bargaining, to submit the terms of a first collective bargaining agreement (CBA) to the Federal
    Mediation and Conciliation Service (FMCS) to attempt a mediated contract agreement. If, after
    90 days of bargaining and/or mediation, no contract agreement is reached, the FMCS will be
    required to submit the terms of the CBA to a binding arbitration panel of three – one arbitrator
    chosen by the Union, one by the Employer, and one by mutual agreement of the Parties. Good
    faith bargaining requires both sides to come to the table with the intent of reaching an
    agreement. I know firsthand and recognize how difficult it is to win a first contract that workers
    can be proud of. I’ve been actively involved in bargaining first contracts as both a rank-and-file
    Teamster and as an elected Teamster business agent. And I recognize that (to put it mildly)
    Employers under current law drag out the bargaining process to frustrate the newly organized
    workers and Union leadership, and to ultimately defeat the Union.

    As the legislative battle over passage of the FLCA moves forward (or not), there will be no
    shortage of Employer actions to defeat the FLCA. I recognize and understand that Employers
    will use any means to buttress their objections to passage of the FLCA, and that might include
    issues I’m raising here. But I believe that organized labor and rank and file workers should be
    open to debate and discussion on the benefits and/or downsides of the FLCA as currently
    written.

    I believe we need to recognize the downside of winning the FLCA alone and without the other
    important and critical provisions of the PRO Act. Our Teamster Constitution, after decades of
    rank-and-file members’ struggle, requires that any CBA be subject to a secret ballot majority
    rule ratification vote by the rank-and-file members of the unit involved. No ratification vote will
    be held if the first contract is imposed by binding arbitration. This may be a means for the

    2

    Union to build a Union culture on the job; the binding arbitration-imposed contract would be
    for two years. The arbitration decision might be (for the workers) great, good, fair, bad, or
    terrible. It will be a roll of the dice. In any event, our Teamsters Constitution would be
    overridden by the FLCA; the rank and file and the Union leadership would be stuck with the
    binding decision by the arbitrator for a period of two years.

    Furthermore, the Union could be striking for a first contract during the initial bargaining,
    mediation, and arbitration period of 90 or more days and be stuck with a binding contract that
    falls far short of a contract acceptable to the Union leadership and the rank and file. Given
    TDU’s history of advocating for the right to strike over grievances, consider the possibility that a
    three-month strike results in a binding contract and workers are forced back to work for 24
    months under a substandard CBA.

    If our Union wants to win passage of any particular provision of the PRO Act, why start with
    the FLCA? Why not start with some of the other provisions of the PRO Act such as: 1) only the
    NLRB and the Union set the union election procedures (the Employer not involved); 2) no
    Employer captive audience meetings; 3) NLRB must immediately go to court seeking an
    injunction to immediately reinstate workers illegally fired for union activity; 4) Employer NLRA
    violations subject to civil penalties and corporate officials held personally accountable for NLRA
    violations; 5) Employee misclassification (independent contractor vs. employee status) would
    violate the NLRA; 6) restoration of the right of Unions to engage in secondary activities; 7) an
    end to permanent replacements (permanent scabs).

    We TDU members know well that the current law protecting workers’ rights to engage in
    concerted activity (collective action involving more than one worker) has no teeth; Employers
    routinely violate that provision of the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) because the only
    penalties imposed on Employers that unlawfully discipline workers because of workers’ union
    activities are: 1) making the workers whole for lost wages/benefits and 2) posting a 60 day
    notice at the workplace that the Employer agrees not to violate the law in the future.

    3

    Furthermore, lost wages are reduced by any wages that the worker(s) were paid during their
    fight to be reinstated. Employers engage in unlawful discipline during a Union organizing drive
    because the historical record shows such violations effectively chill the organizing drive and
    intimidate the workers.

    Why not start with putting real teeth into enforcement of existing law by enacting narrow
    PRO Act provisions such as:
     The NLRB must immediately go to court seeking an injunction to immediately reinstate
    workers illegally fired for union activity;
     Employer NLRA violations become subject to civil penalties and corporate officials held
    personally accountable for NLRA violations.

    The past 45 years have proven that the current penalties under the NLRA don’t stop Employers
    from breaking the law; in fact, Employers recognize that unlawfully discipling workers pays off
    for the Employer in the long run by taking a slap on the wrist from the NLRB, rather than follow
    the NLRA and bargain in good faith for a first contract.

    Turning the tables by making the Employer risk substantial penalties for violating current
    provisions of the NLRA might have a far better chance of becoming law than passage of the
    FLCA. It’s during the early stages of the organizing drive that the Employer sows the seeds of
    fear, divisiveness, and intimidation.

    Don’t get me wrong, the PRO Act in its entirety would be a major transformative law for
    organized labor and workers’ power. But the FLCA by itself, as currently written, could
    potentially work against the Union and rank and file members’ interests. And unquestionably
    the Union will lose a core component of rank-and-file power we in TDU have fought for: the
    right to majority vote ratification of all contracts.

    Getting the Union’s foot in the door, with boiler plate contract provisions, such as no discipline
    without just cause; a grievance procedure; seniority rights on layoffs/recalls, job bids, and
    overtime opportunities; these might be awarded by binding arbitration. All very important non-
    economic provisions, but Unions and rank and file workers should expect and prepare for
    considerable animus from the Employer during the initial two-year binding arbitration contract.
    Employers can be expected, in some cases, to force the Union into binding arbitration, to
    prevent a more comprehensive victory, that the Union might otherwise win in a well-run Union
    struggle for a first contract. And, given that there were over 800 successful Union Yes NLRB
    certified elections in 2025, how effectively can the FMCS be expected to mediate now that
    Trump has gutted the FMCS, leaving a skeleton crew of about 20 FMCS mediators nationwide,
    down from over 200 FMCS mediators when Trump started his second term in 2025?

    I recognize and understand, and don’t dispute that the FLCA could create more favorable
    conditions for some first contract battles, however, we should also recognize that the
    Employers will have the option to force binding arbitration in any NLRA covered bargaining
    unit’s first contract; thereby stopping a well run first contract campaign that might produce a
    much better contract for rank-and-file unit members.

    And what if the arbitrated contract includes a no strike/no lockout provision (as in most
    collective bargaining agreements), but that contract does not provide the rights that all NLRA
    covered workers have without a contract; the right to honor a primary picket line? Will workers
    that choose to exercise that right be subject to discipline or discharge, based on a binding
    contract imposed on the Union? We don’t know where the FLCA is headed, it will be a tough
    legislative battle. But I believe Unions should insist that any binding arbitration contract not
    waive the very important and critical right that most workers already have under federal
    labor law: the right to refuse to cross or work behind any primary picket line. For many
    people and most Union workers, including myself, refusing to cross a picket line is a matter of
    conscience that is sacrosanct and should never be forced upon the Union and its members by
    way of binding arbitration. - Dave Robbins, Teamsters Local 251, retired
  • WTF891
    Senior Member
    • Feb 2024
    • 599

    #2
    This is solid Brother.

    Comment

  • DanaCos
    Senior Member
    • Jan 2023
    • 1014

    #3
    I don't mean to rain on your parade, but you are trying to sound like a philosopher or some sh!t. You running for some kind of office or church decon?There is so much wrong in what you are conveying. You ready for round two bro? You read like Richard Hooker. The only thing about him is he thinks he's Martin Luther King Jr. The only thing with that is MLK wasn't full of himself. Anyway, I'm ready.

    Comment

    • AlJackson1962!
      Senior Member
      • Apr 2024
      • 377

      #4
      Originally posted by DanaCos
      I don't mean to rain on your parade, but you are trying to sound like a philosopher or some sh!t. You running for some kind of office or church decon?There is so much wrong in what you are conveying. You ready for round two bro? You read like Richard Hooker. The only thing about him is he thinks he's Martin Luther King Jr. The only thing with that is MLK wasn't full of himself. Anyway, I'm ready.

      DanaCos: In my post re: the Faster Labor Contracts Act I asked: Please read the below and I would appreciate members thoughts on this matter.

      Thank you for your insight Brother.

      Comment

      • JWebb
        Senior Member
        • Jun 2023
        • 107

        #5
        The FLCA is unworkable if ever ratified and signed. Almost every organizing win will end in arbitration which will plug the system completely, there aren't enough labor arbitrators to go around. And when they start going outside of quality arbitrators with track records we'll end up with more business types not worker types and the contracts will reflect that.

        Unions need a level playing field in Labor law, we don't have it now and FLCA won't get us there. The PRO act is our best shot since Taft-Hartley, lets use our resources fighting for that.

        Comment

        • AlJackson1962!
          Senior Member
          • Apr 2024
          • 377

          #6
          JWebb: I just read your post. I agree. But both the AFL-CIO and IBT are pushing the FLCA. It may come up soon in the Senate. We need to consider avoiding any imposed CBA that doesn’t preserve the right to honor primary picket lines.

          Maybe a petition could generate more focus on this matter.

          Comment

          • WTF891
            Senior Member
            • Feb 2024
            • 599

            #7
            This is about collection of dues through a process that may deny those new members the opportunity to vote on said agreement. I've heard all the arguments about settling for a first contract and building on that. This could result in imposed contracts and dercerts after that.

            Comment

            • Graveyard
              Senior Member
              • May 2023
              • 119

              #8
              Good article on FLCA Brother AL, a detailed explanation of issues!

              In my opinion, workers join unions to have a voice on the job, not to have someone else again tell them what conditions they face at work. FLCA fits right in to O’Brien’s vision of top-down unionism, sit down, shut up, and make sure your dues aren’t late. Examples: Threatens Local 251 members, Rank-N-File in bargaining committees, sure, just sign this NDA. Someone on the GEB speaks against, strip him [Palmer] of duties then start a PR campaign how he is milking the union. Hiring a union busting law firm to shut down a website [TeamsterLink.org] because they used the word “Teamster.”

              What motivates O’Brien’s FLCA support? Perhaps bragging rights, “100,000 New Members” that was easily debunked by the video during his first term when the LM-2’s show less than 1,000 membership increase. Most importantly-plausible deniability, can’t you hear him now, it wasn’t us, it’s the law-the government mediator.

              The FLCA is a weak, water-downed version of the PRO Act. Given the Blue Tsunami, we no longer have to beg Republican’s to pass weak labor laws. O’Brien declared that "The Teamsters are the greatest fucking union in the world" during the Convention. OK, then show some real leadership demanding improvements to the PRO Act, its passage and by holding Dems accountable to their stated values.

              But hey, it’s O’Brien, don’t hold your breath waiting!

              Comment

              • DanaCos
                Senior Member
                • Jan 2023
                • 1014

                #9
                Originally posted by AlJackson1962!


                DanaCos: In my post re: the Faster Labor Contracts Act I asked: Please read the below and I would appreciate members thoughts on this matter.

                Thank you for your insight Brother.
                Let me go nuke a bag of jiffy pop. Be right back!

                Comment

                • AlJackson1962!
                  Senior Member
                  • Apr 2024
                  • 377

                  #10
                  Graveyard makes very valid points, as have JWebb and WTF891.
                  Looks like a US Senate vote might come close to 60 for the FLCA. for cloture. But Trump will almost certainly veto it, and that will require 2/3 of the US Senate and House to overturn his veto.
                  I believe there have certainly been newly organized units that may have benefitted from an FLCA scenario. But as stated above, the FLCA will impact every NLRA covered unit's first contract; that's a huge change. And O'Brien has used the FLCA as a means for him to personally ally himself with right wing extremist politicians (Hawley, Mullin, Chavez-Deremer, Abbott, Moody, etc.).
                  O'Brien uses his new found right wing allies support for the FLCA as a "fig leaf"* to hide their true colors - they are anti-union to the core.
                  *I borrow this characterization "fig leaf" from Strike author Jeremy Brecher.
                  The FLCA as currently written will not be a step forward in my view.

                  Comment

                  • WTF891
                    Senior Member
                    • Feb 2024
                    • 599

                    #11
                    The Dems should push for the PRO Act and nothing less.

                    Comment

                    • AlJackson1962!
                      Senior Member
                      • Apr 2024
                      • 377

                      #12
                      Originally posted by WTF891
                      The Dems should push for the PRO Act and nothing less.
                      WTF891: I'm good with that. However, we don't know how the Dems will proceed, given that the FLCA has already passed the House. We could get whipsawed into passage of the FLCA as a fallback strategy, if the PRO Act is shot down. Besides discussion on this site, has anyone witnessed labor unions disavowing the Faster Labor Contracts Act? I have not seen any groundswell regarding the downside of the FLCA.

                      Comment

                      Working...